Privacy News Highlights
13–25 October 2006
Contents:
CA – B.C.
Considers Biometric ID for Driver’s Licences
CA – National Secrets Law Ruled Unconstitutional
CA – Lawyer Fights for Right to Privacy in Ontario
Adoption Law
CA – PEI Rolls Out Enhanced Driver’s License to Islanders
WW – ID Theft Warning for Yahoo & Hotmail E-Mail
US – MSNBC Privacy Survey Reveals Consumers Value
Convenience Over Privacy
CA – Ottawa Reviewing Billion-Dollar Secure Channel
CA – Survey: Majority of GTA Residents Support Online
Voting
AU – Graduate School Mistakenly Sends Alums Entire Email
Database
AU – Audit Finds Australia e-Records Patchy
CA – Privacy Commissioner Releases Guidelines on
Identification and Authentication
US – Ponemon Institute Study: Data Breach Costs Escalate
In 2006
US – Sociology Professor Publishes Privacy Encyclopedia
UK – Research: UK Household Trash a Gold Mine for ID
Thieves
US – U.S. Government Defends 1998 Anti-Porn Law
EU – Swiss Official Says Banks Broke Law by Supplying
Data to U.S.
UK – ID Theft Risk on Bank Websites
WW – SEC: Hackers Increasingly Target Online Stock
Accounts
MY – Banks: Online Banking Fraud Result of Phishing, Not
Intrusion
UK – Morgan Stanley ID Theft Risk Calculator Launched
CA – Access to Information Researcher Complains of
Government Profiling
CA – Hackers Steal Personal Information from Brock
University Computers
CA – Ontario Commissioner Announces Plan to Create New
Online Identity System
WW – FBI Expert Says Electronic Age Makes ID Theft Much
Easier
US – ID Theft Up 21% this Year
US – Class Action Suit Over ID Theft Tossed Out
WW – IBM Launches Global Initiative to Help Clients
Detect Threat and Combat Fraud
US – Ben Edelman vs. TRUSTe Web Seals
AU – New Web Site Teaches Online Safety
US – Data Retention Endorsed by FBI, International
Association of Chiefs of Police
EU – EU gives US Prosecutors Access to Criminal Cases
Data
IN – Legislation Would Impose Security and Privacy
Protections on Outsourcing Industry
CA – Ontario Privacy Commissioner Cavoukian on Privacy
& Social Networking
CH – China Moves Toward ‘Real Name System’ for Blogs
WW – Microsoft Announces Guidelines to Help Developers
Protect Customers’ Privacy
US – Privacy Group Sues FBI for Database Info
US – ChoicePoint Names a "Consumer Advocate"
US – Judge Limits Ability to Search Laptops at Borders
RFID – EU Commissioner Calls for RFID Privacy
Enhancements
WW – Researchers Reveal Potential Security, Privacy Flaws
in New RFID Credit Cards
US – DHS Proposes Vicinity RFID Technology for PASSport
Card
US – Smart Card Alliance: Use of Long Range RFID’s in
Passports Bad for Privacy
EU – Project to Track Passengers in Airports Using RFID
WW – The DeadMan’s Handle: Failsafe For Laptop Security
WW – Microsoft Accepts Outside Security Vendors for Vista
AU – Australia Privacy Commissioner Urges System Thinking
on Smartcard
US – US Gov’t to Roll Out New Employee ID Card
EU – Finnish Government Employees Get Chip ID Cards
EU – E-Passport Launched in Ireland
EU – Dutch Police Ordered More Internet Surveillance in
2005, Industry Groups Says
CA – Ontario Government Spends $2 Million for TO
Surveillance Cams
US – FTC Rejects Industry Efforts to Allow Recorded Calls
US – Report: Federal Government Agencies Have Sloppy Data
Privacy Practices
US – States Continue to Ban Pretexting While Congress
Talks Tough
US – DoE Ends Polygraph Screening of Job Applicants,
Employees
B.C. could soon become the first Canadian jurisdiction
to imprint driver’s licences with fingerprints or other biometric features. The
province is studying the biometric technology, which, according to B.C.
Solicitor General, would bolster the argument against controversial American
plans to require passports for Canadians visiting the
An
An
The PEI Department of Transportation and Public Works
has begun offering an enhanced driver’s license to Islanders. The new driver’s
license is part of an initiative of the four
Web retailers should stop accepting transactions from
customers using Yahoo and Hotmail email addresses, according to
credit-reference agency checkmyfile. The company said retailers accepting
transactions from the popular web-based email services are up to 7 times more
likely to have to refund the owners’ credit cards due to fraudulent activity. [Source]
Bob Sullivan, technology correspondent for MSNBC.com,
reveals the results of a 30-question privacy survey developed with the help of
Larry Ponemon, founder of The Ponemon Institute. More than 6,500 MSNBC.com
users voluntarily took the survey, which Ponemon said revealed some surprising
results. Users do not trust the government or organizations with their
information and see an erosion in their privacy. Despite this dim view, they
generally are eager to share personal details online in exchange for convenience,
according to the survey results. [Source]
An internal document that was published this week says
Canada Revenue Agency has ordered a review of Secure Channel, the system used
at the federal level to transact a variety of public services. According to the
document, Secure Channel is riddled with bugs and has experienced a series of
crashes, poorly timed upgrades and administration problems. It also revealed
that the cost of Secure Channel is going way up - from $600,000 at the moment
to an expected $1 billion by the end of the decade. Even the Canada Revenue
Agency Review is to cost $100,000. For a country that has regular sat atop a
worldwide Accenture survey of online public sector achievements, this is a
portrait of everything e-government is not supposed to be - unreliable,
inefficient and expensive. [Source]
[Source]
[Source]
[Source]
A new survey suggests a large majority of residents
living in the GTA would rather vote online if the method were offered in
municipal elections. The poll, sponsored by Delvinia Interactive, released this
week found 69% of residents planning to vote in the Nov. 13 election would
prefer the high-tech way of casting ballots as opposed to the traditional
method of lining up at polling stations. Of those not planning to vote, 82%
said the Internet option would increase their likelihood of voting. [Source]
[Source]
The Alumni office of the Macquarie Graduate School of
Management accidentally sent its email database containing 25,000 addresses to
every graduate. The school has apologized for the error, which it blamed on a
technical error. [Source]
An audit of three Australian federal agencies has
found a patchy approach to electronic record-keeping. The audit, which examined
the record keeping practices of the Attorney-General’s Department, the Australian
Electoral Commission and the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet,
examined all facets of the agencies’ archiving practices. All three agencies
used a mixture of paper-based and electronic systems. But the audit found
electronic records caused particular problems, echoing findings from two previous
reports. [Source]
Consumer groups, artists’ organizations and copyright
owners clashed on whether digital rights management tools would help increase
A study released this week shows that data breaches
have become more costly this year to
The Encyclopedia of Privacy, edited by William G.
Staples, professor and chair of the Department of Sociology at the
Research by the business advisor Waste Works shows
that more than 21 million
Eight years after Congress passed a law aimed at
protecting children from online pornography, free speech advocates and Web site
publishers argued in federal court this week that the never-enforced measure is
fatally flawed. Salon.com, Nerve.com, and other plaintiffs warned that the 1998
Child Online Protection Act could be
used to criminalize such things as sexual health information, erotic literature
and news photographs of naked prisoners tortured at Abu Ghraib. [Source]
Swiss banks broke their nation’s laws by providing
banking information to American counterterrorism officials,
Three
Hackers
have been breaking into customer accounts at large online brokerages in the
The Association of Malaysian Banks said 159 online
banking fraud cases during the first 9 months of 2006 were mainly the result of
phishing, not intrusion into the banks’ Internet banking systems. The group
said that Internet banking systems are secure. Banks and customers must do
their parts to tackle online fraud, the banking group says. Consumer education
is critical to foil the fraudsters. [Source]
In order to help the battle against the risk of ID
theft, Morgan Stanley has introduced an ID theft risk calculator to give
customers the chance to weigh up the likelihood of them falling victim to the
crime. Found on the Morgan Stanley website, the ID theft risk calculator works
by posing a series of questions relating to specific aspects of card usage. The
risk calculator asks questions on four subjects: home, finances, lifestyle and
personal details, so that the level of risk an individual faces due to their
habits can be effectively assessed. Level of risk is displayed by a green and
red warning system with the aim of making people more aware of the risk they
may run regarding ID theft. [Source]
Testifying
before a parliamentary committee, Ken Rubin revealed that he learned recently
he has been the subject of just such a profile. Documents Rubin obtained from
the Canadian Border Services Agency revealed a memo prepared in January 2004
for then-public safety minister Anne McLellan outlining an access request that
Rubin had filed for information concerning the department’s Advance Passenger
Information project. In the memo, which the department told Rubin was never
transmitted all the way to the minister, the department outlines details of
telephone calls officials had with Rubin, other access requests he had filed
and the fact that he had volunteered to help Maher Arar and his wife get
information about their case. The memo was released to Rubin earlier this month
under the Access to Information Act after he filed a complaint. [Source]
[Government
‘Abusing Public’s Right to Know] [Open letter
Regarding TB President John Baird’s possible breach of privacy laws]
The personal information – Including some credit card
and bank account numbers – of about 70,000 people who gave money to
Speaking
in
US – FBI Warns Online Jobseekers of
Identity Theft
The
Internet makes it easier to look for a new job. By posting your resume on a
number of popular jobs sites, it’s easier for employers to find you. Unfortunately,
it’s also easier for identity thieves to find you. The FBI says it increasingly
receives reports of job seekers being contacted by criminals out to steal their
identity. Posing as a potential employer, the scammer requests more
information, including sensitive data like social security number and date of
birth. Many people fall victim to this scam because they think the request is
legitimate, and the information is needed for a background check. Instead, the
information is used to open credit card accounts and lines of credit in the
victim’s name. For job hunting online, the FBI has some advice: [Source][Source]
o
Don’t give out a SSN until you’re sure of the
identity of the person making the request.
o
Don’t agree to a background check until after an
interview in person.
o
Never set up a direct deposit until officially hired,
and
o
When applying online, target specific employers and
don’t blanket the web with resumes.
Anti-fraud group Cifas has released a study that finds
that identity theft will affect 70,000 people by the end of the year. In the
first nine months of 2006, ID fraud cases have increased 21%, affecting nearly
double the number of victims four years ago. The study finds that one of the
most productive fraud methods involves raiding the garbage for enough personal
information to steal a person’s identity. A study last week confirmed this
trend when experts who examined the trash discarded in bins on a south
A federal judge in
IBM has announced a comprehensive software and
solutions strategy expected to provide customers with the industry’s most
advanced and complete identity recognition solutions for uncovering and
managing potential threats and fraudulent activity by individuals and groups
attempting to mask, hide, or misrepresent their identities. IBM’s Threat &
Fraud Intelligence strategy will enable five focused solution portfolios with a
common, extensible and re-usable technology platform - each tailored to meet
the needs of a specific industry or focus area. [Source]
In his recently published paper, author and spyware
researcher Ben Edelman concluded that, out of a sampling of over 500,000 top
sites, 5.4% of TRUSTe-certified sites are actually untrustworthy, compared with
2.5% of all sites in the test group. “So,” he writes, “TRUSTe-certified sites
are more than twice as likely to be untrustworthy.” Edelman singles out sites
he believes should not have been awarded the TRUSTe privacy seal, some of which
still remain approved. He also criticizes the ability of Better Business Bureau
seal programs and major search engines to shield users from potential dangers
of visiting or interacting with certain sites. Edelman contends most users
expect a privacy certification process to consider spyware or e-mail abuse.
Thus, he concluded, by separating privacy policy adherence from other nefarious
activities, “I don’t think [TRUSTe] passes the smell taste with most users.” [Source]
A new Australian government Web site aims to teach
people how to avoid Internet pitfalls. The regularly updated site offers advice
such as how to protect children from online predators, how to spot a money
scam, and how to guard against viruses. [Source]
The International Association of Chiefs of Police
(IACP) has endorsed the concept of data retention in a resolution. The IACP
resolution seeks data retention being extended from ISPs to registrars and
registries. Search engines have also been talked about as potential targets.
And FBI
director Robert Mueller applauded them a few hours later: [Source] [Source]
[Source]
[Source]
The EU
and the
In
response to a recent British television report that highlighted data security
shortcomings in the outsourcing industry, the government this week strengthened
the Information Technology Act, 2000, with amendments that require corporations
and organizations that have access to customers’ personal information to adopt
security practices. The amended bill will be introduced next month in the
winter session of parliament. [Source]
[Source]
[Indian
Cabinet Amends IT Act for Data Protection]
Posting your personal information on a social
networking website without considering your privacy options is like crossing
the street without looking both ways, says Ontario Information and Privacy Commissioner
Ann Cavoukian. Neither is advisable. The Commissioner and social networking
website Facebook released a joint brochure, When Online Gets Out of Line:
Privacy - Make an Informed Online Choice, which encourages university,
college and high school students to carefully consider their privacy options
before hitting “send.” “Social networking sites are becoming a significant
technological and social phenomenon,” said the Commissioner. “These websites
help to connect people with various interests and are becoming increasingly
popular with university and college students. They can offer basic information
about people and also provide blogs, chat rooms and discussion forums. There
are hundreds, if not thousands, of these websites. Most offer students minimal
protection.” [Source]
The Internet Society of China has recommended to the
government that bloggers be required to use their real names when they register
blogs in the latest attempt to regulate free-wheeling Web content. The society,
which is affiliated with the Ministry of Information Industry, said no decision
had been made but that a ‘real name system’ was inevitable. [Source]
The Privacy Guidelines for
Developing Software Products and Services, released at the
The Electronic Frontier Foundation has sued the U.S.
government for information about an FBI database of more than 700 million
personal records set up after the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks, because the FBI
failed to respond to Freedom of Information Act requests on its “Investigative
Data Warehouse.” The lawsuit also charges the FBI has not posted a public
notice describing the criteria on personal information included in the
database, as required by the Privacy Act of 1974. [Source]
[Your Papers, Please!
Fighting the Total Surveillance Society]
ChoicePoint, whose name has become synonymous with
“data breach,” has created a new “Consumer Advocate” position in hopes of
cleaning up its image. The job is designed to address, as ChoicePoint president
Doug Curling put it, “the need for us to be more transparent to the consumer
and more receptive to their concerns.” The first individual to hold the
position is Katherine Bryant. [Source]
Government officials must have reasonable suspicion
under the Fourth Amendment to search someone’s laptop at
A European Commission survey of nearly 2,200 people
has revealed privacy concerns related to the use of RFID tags. 70% of
respondents indicated they favor revealing the tags by notice to consumers as
well as providing an opportunity to disable or destroy them. The survey,
conducted over six months, found that people and organizations are concerned
about losing control of their data collected by the tags and the possibility of
surveillance. Information society and media commissioner Viviane Reding said
she would consider legislation to give consumers privacy protections. [Source] [Source]
[EU needs RFID privacy
regs, study finds] [Privacy Law
in the Cards?] [EC
Final Report] [Source]
[Source]
[EU
to tackle radio chip privacy fears] [Source]
[Source]
A new generation of credit cards that require no
swiping may have some privacy and security challenges, according to researchers
who did a public demonstration to reveal the shortcomings. Companies that issue
the cards said the academic exercise was interesting, but the demonstration
does not translate into real risks for consumers. The companies have given
consumers the impression that the data was encrypted to prevent hackers from
obtaining sensitive information. However, the researchers say they were able to
obtain the cardholder’s name and other details – all unencrypted. [Source]
[Report
Reveals RFID Credit Cards Ripe for Info Skimming] [Source] [Source]
[Source]
[CASPIAN
Advises Consumers to Immediately Remove Cards from Wallets]
The U.S. Department of Homeland Security and
Department of State have spelled out plans for the use of the RFID-enabled
PASSport card at
Using the long read range radio frequency
identification (RFID) technology the Department of Homeland Security and State
Department are proposing for passport cards will do little to increase the security
of the nation’s borders, and opens up possibilities that
More often the not, laptop thieves are after hardware
and stumble upon information. DeadMan’s Handle is designed to delete secure
information in the event a laptop is stolen. When the laptop is turned onby the
thief a prompt designated by the user is presented. If the proper answer to the
“innocuous-looking challenge” is not entered DeadMan’s Handle “quietly deletes
the confidential information ... on the machine” and deletes itself. Account
numbers, personal files, or even remote network configuration files can all be
deemed confidential. Harmless warnings about virus protection expirations or
innocent looking update panels are among the 70 different challenges the
program can be shipped with. [Source]
Microsoft Corp. did an about-face, agreeing to make it
easier for customers of its forthcoming
The Australian Privacy Commissioner has urged the
federal government to recognize the proposed Smartcard will be a system, not
just a standalone card, and that new laws will be need to protect privacy when
the smartcard is introduced. And it is also warning the government against
allowing the kind of function creep which overtook the Canadian Social
Insurance Number to plague the so-called Access Card. In its submission to the
government’s Access Card Consumer and Privacy Taskforce, the Office of the
Privacy Commissioner argues existing protections won’t alleviate the threat to
privacy posed by the introduction of the health and welfare Access Card. The
government plans for the card to replace 17 existing social services cards. [Source]
Beginning Oct. 27 and continuing over the next two
years,
Chip ID cards for government employees are being
adopted throughout Finnish central government. The photo ID cards contain a
qualified certificate enabling identification to log into information networks,
authentication of network users and their usage rights, encryption of email and
other documents and provision of a binding and undisputable electronic
signature, as specified in Finnish legislation. [Source]
Dutch police have been steadily increasing their
surveillance of Internet users suspected of crimes, an industry group of
Internet service providers said in a statement last week. Since 2002, Dutch
ISPs have been obliged to provide police with tapping services on request.
There were six such taps ordered in 2003, the
CCTVs in high-risk neighbourhoods will help keep
After receiving thousands of comments from consumers
opposed to an industry request to allow more recorded telemarketing pitches
without consumer consent, the FTC has denied the petition filed by Voice
Message Broadcasting Corp. of
The House Government Reform Committee released a
report last week that warns that personal information held by the federal
government “remains at risk.” The committee had asked agencies to provide details
about the loss or compromise of any sensitive personal information by the
departments or its contractors since Jan. 1, 2003. The report documented the
theft of more than 1,800 government-owned laptop computers. In addition, those
agencies don’t always know what information has been lost or how many people
could be affected because they aren’t tracking those losses, the report said.
Only a small number of the data breaches were caused by hackers breaking into
computer systems. Most of the data losses stemmed from the theft of laptops,
drives and disks, as well as unauthorized use of the information by employees.
Contractors were also responsible for many of the reported breaches. [Source]
[Theft causes most data
losses, report finds] [Report:
Data loss widespread at government agencies] [Source]
Despite impassioned calls in
The U.S. Energy Department plans to end its
across-the-board polygraph testing of job applicants and employees, according
to a rule that department officials published in the Federal Register. The
policy change becomes effective Oct. 30. Some researchers say there have been
no major physiological or technological advances in the past few years to
justify the use of polygraphs for employee security screening at federal
agencies. Opponents of polygraph testing have argued for years that DOE and
other agencies should scrap such evaluations. Now, after ignoring studies that
show that polygraphs are not reliably accurate, DOE has decided to decrease its
reliance on such testing for screening prospective counterintelligence
employees. DOE screens employees using a computerized polygraph system to
prevent insiders from leaking classified information to the country’s enemies.
The department has been administering polygraphs to all employees, consultants
and contractor employees before granting them access to sensitive information.
[Source]
--------