Privacy News Highlights
21–27 September 2007
Contents:
CA –
Inadequate Security Safeguards Led to TJX Breach, Commissioners Say
CA – Identity, Privacy and Security Initiative (IPSI)
Launched
CA – New Brunswick. Privacy Laws ‘Hopelessly Outdated’:
Report
CA – British Columbia to Test Digital ID Card
AU – One Privacy Breach a Day at CentreLink
CA – Ontario Couple Receives Eight Election Forms
WW – International Privacy Experts Meet In Montreal
EU – Hustinx Condemns Weakening of EU Data Protection
US – Verizon Rejects Abortion Rights Group’s Text
Messages
US – Trans Union, Equifax Reverse Policy, Offer Consumers
Credit Freeze in 50 States
CA – Taxman Goes Browsing on eBay for Tax Avoiders
CA – Public Data Being Withheld: Freedom of Information
Study
CA – Freedom of Information Flow Easier on American Side
of Canada-U.S. Border
NZ – Worrying Secrecy Exposed In New Zealand Govt
Agencies
CA – P.E.I. Information Requests Way Down
EU – France Plans to Screen Visa-Seekers’ DNA
US – Drug Info Firms Target Vermont Prescriber Data Laws
US – Mortgage Data on 5,200 Customers Exposed through
Filesharing Network
US – University of Michigan Suffers Another Data Security
Breach
US – “Security Measures Enhance Privacy”, Chertoff Says
at Montreal Conference
US – Supreme Court to Hear Case on Indiana Voter ID Law
WW – Google to Create Canadian Version of Street View
WW – Google Says Global Privacy Rules Needed Within Five
Years
US – U.S. Agent Indicted for Using Homeland Security
Database to Stalk Girlfriend
WW – MySpace Has Data-Mining Plans
UK – Social Networking 6-In-10 Users Protect Their
Identity by Giving False Information
SA – South Africa Preparing First Privacy Law
US – Judge Rules Two Provisions of Patriot Act
Unconstitutional
US – Idaho Pulls Out of REAL ID, Alaska DMV Sued
US – TJX Agrees to Settlement in U.S. Class Action Suit
US – Companies Still Not Taking Adequate Measures to Wipe
Used Drives
WW – Survey: Employee Error Fuels Data Security Breaches
UK - New Data: CCTV Ineffective On Solving Crimes
US – New Service Eavesdrops on Net Calls to Display
Targeted Ads
US – Ruling Eases U.S. Government’s Efforts for Cell
Phone Tracking
US – New Legislation Would Reform National Security
Letters
CA – Security Clearance Deadline Looms for Port Workers
An investigation by the Privacy Commissioners of
Canada and Alberta has found that the risk of a breach of sensitive personal
information held by TJX, the US parent company of Winners and HomeSense stores
in Canada, was foreseeable, but the company failed to put in place adequate
security safeguards. “The company collected too much personal information, kept
it too long and relied on weak encryption technology to protect it – putting
the privacy of millions of its customers at risk,” said Privacy Commissioner of
Canada Jennifer Stoddart, adding that “The TJX breach is a dramatic example of
how keeping large amounts of sensitive information – particularly information
that is not required for business purposes – for a long time can be a serious
liability.” Frank Work, the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Alberta,
said: “This case is a wake-up call for all retailers. They must collect only
the personal information necessary for a transaction.” [Source] [Report] [Source]
A new university program has been launched to address
the need for a more holistic approach to privacy, identity and security
management. The Identity, Privacy and Security Initiative (IPSI) was created by
the University of Toronto to develop new approaches to security that maintain
privacy, freedom and safety of the user and the broader community. As a result
of the initiative, the U. of T. has launched two new interdisciplinary masters
level programs leading to either a Masters of Professional Engineering (M.Eng),
or a Masters of Information Studies with concentration on security (MISt). In a
release from Ontario’s Information and Privacy Commissioner, Ann Cavoukian said
that “In essence, the IPSI program will not only educate future generations on
how to build privacy into technology, but it will also hopefully develop a
culture of privacy - a way of thinking that is committed to better information
management and the protection of privacy.” For further information visit www.ipsi.utoronto.ca [Source] See also: [The Privacy Prognosis: Protect it
like Fort Knox] [IPC
website: more info]
New Brunswick’s access-to-information and privacy laws
are “hopelessly outdated,” and an overhaul is needed, according to a new
report. The report, headed by Donald Savoie, Canada research chair in public
administration and governance at the University of Moncton, says the laws are
too complicated. It says there should be a single statute combining the Protection of Personal Information Act
with the Right to Information Act. In
an unusual move, the report was made available to the public at the same time
it was handed in to the government. The authors said it was completed for about
$19,000, more than $130,000 under budget. The 43 recommendations aim to promote
a more “open and transparent” democratic system in the province. [Source]
[Final Report]
British Columbia will test a virtual ID “card” that
enables citizens to connect with the government’s online services more safely
and easily, a top technology official said. The government plans to begin tests
on an “information card” early in the new year. The cards are in the early
stages, and “there’s going to be some challenges,” Bailey said. An information
card is not a card at all: it’s more like a document delivered to users’
computers which they can then use to access government websites. It’s meant to
replace the current method of access, which involves logging on to a site with
a name and password, and has a digital signature that can’t be changed or reproduced.
Among other attributes, using an information card means:
·
The
government won’t know which sites the user visits.
·
The
user is in control of shared information.
·
The
cards won’t have to reveal users’ birthdates or addresses, or a student’s
school.
Instead, it could simply confirm the user is over 19,
a B.C. resident or a student. He compared using the card to using a driver’s
licence for identification since, in both cases, the government does not know
what the citizen is doing. [Source] See
also: [NZ joint
winner of global online identity award]
Australia’s CentreLink says its staff breached privacy
regulations 367 times in the past financial year, but only two employees were
sacked. The federal welfare support agency’s checks also identified 289
conflict of interest cases. Of the proven privacy and code of conduct breaches,
24 employees resigned and two had their employment terminated. Another 296
employees received a written warning, 13 were reprimanded and 44 were fined or
had their salary reduced. [Source]
An Ontario couple received multiple
notice-of-registration cards in the mail this week, in advance of the Oct. 10
provincial election and referendum. “I got four of them addressed to me, and my
wife got four addressed to her. This is a waste of taxpayers’ money.” The
double-sided forms confirm a resident’s inclusion on the official voters’ list,
and point them to the appropriate polling station. Peter received four of the
cards, and so did his wife. “There are only three of us here, and (our
8-month-old son) can’t vote,” the couple added. While the names and addresses
are identical, the several-digit number accompanying the bar code on each form
differs, he noted. “I wondered if the computer was spitting out four of the
same (forms), but it’s obviously not,” he added. [Source]
The world’s top privacy experts met in Montreal this
week to explore emerging new threats to privacy. The Office of the Privacy
Commissioner of Canada hosted the 29th International Conference of Data
Protection and Privacy Commissioners, the key international privacy event each
year, from September 25th to 28th. Workshops addressed privacy in the context
of public safety, globalization, Radio Frequency Identification, children and
the Internet, location-based tracking, data mining, Internet crime and many
other topics. Leading international experts on all of these topics attended the
conference. Speakers include US Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff,
who gave a keynote address on privacy and public security; Google global
privacy counsel Peter Fleischer; author and privacy and security expert Bruce
Schneier, prominent consumer privacy advocate Katherine Albrecht as well as
global privacy campaigners such as Simon Davies of Privacy International. [Source]
Europe’s Data Protection Supervisor, Peter Hustinx,
says the EU is weakening planned privacy protection in order to secure
agreement for the Data Protection Framework Decision (DPFD), a proposed basis
for police data sharing across Europe. He says the agreement threatens to
reduce privacy protection in Europe. Hustinx has three times raised serious
objections to the way negotiations over the DPFD have progressed. He also
previously called for a proportionality of response to data, so that a suspect’s
data would be treated differently to that of a witness or a convicted person.
He has now raised another serious concern, which is that the negotiations have
produced a compromise by which protection will only be extended to data coming
from another country. [Source]
Saying it had the right to block “controversial or
unsavory” text messages, Verizon Wireless has rejected a request from Naral
Pro-Choice America, the abortion rights group, to make Verizon’s mobile network
available for a text-message program. The other leading wireless carriers have
accepted the program, which allows people to sign up for text messages from
Naral by sending a message to a five-digit number known as a short code. [Source]
In a surprise reversal and a major win for consumers,
the Trans Union credit bureau announced that it would offer consumers the
ability to “freeze” their credit files in all 50 states in order to protect
themselves against identity theft and fraud. The service will be available in
the 11 states that do not already have credit-freeze laws, costing consumers
$10 to set the freeze and $10 to unlock it, and will “meet or exceed the
requirements” of states with existing freeze laws. The freeze service will be
free to victims of identity theft, and is scheduled to roll out Oct. 15. Consumer
advocates hailed Trans Union’s decision and urged the remaining bureaus to
follow suit. Equifax followed suit, announcing this week that it too would
offer credit freezes for customers in all 50 states, and would roll out its own
plan sometime in October. Experian remains
undecided. Credit freezes and associated protection plans represent a
potentially lucrative new revenue stream for the bureaus to make use of. But as
Consumers Union’s Hillebrand notes, if the bureaus have the technical means to
enable instant locking and unlocking of credit, they should not be charging
high fees to use a service that can be turned on and off in minutes. “TransUnion
and the rest of the credit bureaus should follow the lead of the states with
the best security freeze laws and provide this protection to all consumers for
no more than $5,” Hillebrand said. “All three credit bureaus should make it
fast, affordable, and easy for consumers nationwide to take advantage of this
important identity theft safeguard.” [Source]
[TransUnion
press release]
The Canada Revenue Agency has won a Federal Court
order requiring eBay Canada to turn over the names, addresses, phone numbers
and e-mail addresses of all high-volume sellers on the popular website. The CRA
wants to find out whether those individuals or companies are reporting the
income they made from online sales in 2004 and 2005. According to their
affidavit, the CRA is seeking to verify compliance with the obligations and
duties under the Income Tax Act of
certain Canadian taxpayers selling goods in an online marketplace. [Source]
When journalists from across Canada asked government
officials for 85 public records ranging from court documents to local water quality
reports to federal food safety warnings, the answer was “no” nearly half the
time. Even after filing formal written requests under information laws,
journalists were still unable to pry basic public records from government
filing cabinets in 40% of cases. Findings from the third
annual National Freedom of Information Audit illustrate how government
secrecy undermines the public’s right to know, says Anne Kothawala, president
of the Canadian Newspaper Association, which conducted the audit. “Year after
year, newspapers show through this exercise that many Canadian governments have
a flawed understanding of the importance of transparency to the democratic system.
But transparency is exactly what underpins the accountability principle at the
heart of it all. “You can’t have one without the other.” Over a period of two
months, more than 40 journalists visited provincial court offices, federal
government departments and city halls documenting how public servants respond
to requests for public information. [Source] [3rd
Annual Audit] [Great
Wall Of Secrecy] [Commissioner
Ann Cavoukian sending out four teams for Right to Know Blitz Day, Sept. 28]
Canada and the United States share a commitment to
freedom, but, when filing freedom of information requests, fact-seekers
generally find an easier flow on the U.S. side of the border. If the U.S.
system bogs down, however - as it often does if the question even remotely
touches on national security - then be prepared to pay some fat legal fees,
with no guarantee of success. Yet on both sides of the border, sensitive FOI
requests can and do languish for years. Also shared in the post-9/11 age,
critics say, is a growing sense among access-seekers that, at high levels of
government, secrecy rather than forthrightness is the norm. [Source]
National Party State Services spokesman Gerry Brownlee
says the Office of the Ombudsmen has exposed a worrying trend in government
agency secrecy that needs to be remedied. “Government agencies can’t pick and
choose when they should follow the law. The proper release of public
information is a vital cog in our democracy.” Mr Brownlee is commenting on the
release of the Office of the Ombudsmen’s Annual Report which has been tabled in
Parliament. The report has slammed government agencies for claiming that
information is so sensitive that the Official
Information Act should not apply. Mr Brownlee says any Government committed
to openness and transparency would take the Ombudsmen’s views seriously. “This
has potentially far-reaching consequences. [Source] [Ombudsman
2007 Annual Report] See also: [Cayman
Islands, Long A Privacy Haunt, Celebrates ASNE-Inspired ‘Sunshine Week’]
The number of access-to-information requests in P.E.I.
has dropped significantly since the province’s freedom-of-information
legislation first came into effect in 2003. Karen Rose, the provincial freedom-of-information
and privacy commissioner, said this week that in 2003, the number of requests
to government bodies was 161. That dropped to 59 last year. “We expected a lot
of requests for the first couple of years simply because the legislation was
new. We did expect a levelling out at some point,” Rose said. But Rose isn’t
convinced that’s the only factor at play. She said she believes some government
bodies are more likely to simply hand over information now, rather than force
people to go through a formal process. [Source]
The French National Assembly last week approved a
controversial proposal authorizing the use of DNA testing to determine whether
foreigners applying for visas are actually related to family members they seek
to join in France. The plan, part of President Nicolas Sarkozy’s efforts to
make it tougher for foreigners from Middle Eastern and African countries to
immigrate to France, prompted outrage from human rights groups, opposition
politicians and some members of the president’s cabinet. [Source] See also: [Gene
information opens new frontier in privacy debate]
Doctors do not have a privacy right to their
prescription-writing habits, data-collection firms say as they sue in Vermont
and Maine. After landing a first-round federal court victory against a 2006 New
Hampshire prescriber privacy law, data-gathering firms are targeting similar
laws set to take effect next year in Maine and Vermont. Legislators in those
two states, wary of a similar legal upset, shied away from a New
Hampshire-style ban on any marketing use of prescriber data. Instead, they
crafted legislation allowing physicians and other prescribers to choose whether
drugmakers can access their prescription data. In Maine, doctors could opt out
of data sharing; in Vermont, they could opt in. But
prescription-data-collection firms IMS Health Inc., Verispan LLC and Source
Healthcare Analytics Inc. filed federal lawsuits in late August challenging the
new laws. The complaints argue that they violate the U.S. Constitution’s First
and 14th Amendments as well as the Commerce Clause. “The problem with the Maine
and Vermont laws is that they create an entirely new and unprecedented privacy
right for physicians in their professional conduct,” an IMS spokesman said. The
U.S. District Court of New Hampshire ruled last spring that the state’s
prescriber privacy law infringes on constitutionally protected commercial
speech rights. The court also concluded that physicians do not have a privacy
right in their prescribing habits. In August, New Hampshire Attorney General
appealed the decision to the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. A ruling is not
expected before next year. The state medical societies in New Hampshire,
Vermont and Maine backed their states’ prescriber privacy legislation. [Source] See
also: [Physician
Prescribing Data Information Center] [AMA website][AMA Physician Data Restriction
Program]. [AMA
Therapeutic Insights].
Personally identifiable information of more than 5,200
ABN Amro Mortgage customers was leaked to the Internet. A former ABN employee
had BearShare filesharing software installed on her computer, which allowed the
leak of the ABN spreadsheets as well as some of her own personal information.
The leaked data include SSNs. The company is investigating. There is legitimate
concern that the information could be used to commit identity fraud; a man was
recently arrested in Washington state for misusing information he obtained
through filesharing networks. [Source]
[Source]
[Source] [Source]
For the third time in one year, the University of
Michigan has suffered a data theft. Several weeks ago, backup tapes containing
personally identifiable patient information were stolen from the School of
Nursing. The compromised data include names, addresses and SSNs. More than
8,000 individuals have been affected by this incident. The university has
notified those affected by the theft. The other two incidents of compromised
data involved direct cyber attacks; this was the first instance in which
storage media were stolen. [Source]
[Source]
Secure identification and sharing international
passenger lists boost security with the added bonus of protecting privacy, U.S.
Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff told skeptical privacy watchdogs this
week. Chertoff said new ID cards with chips and other tough-to-copy features
prevent identification theft from innocent people. Chertoff added that
passenger lists and other shared intelligence on the 80 million people who fly
into the U.S. every year allow security officials to drastically narrow down
their targets for arrival screening. “I think by focusing on people who are the
higher risk, we are net increasing privacy for the vast majority of innocent
travellers,” Chertoff said. Chertoff’s contentious speech to open the
conference was met with skepticism and outright hostility. [Source] [Security
czar says freedom comes at a cost] [U.S.
Homeland security chief says personal information needed on travellers]
With the 2008 presidential and Congressional elections
on the horizon, the Supreme Court agreed to consider whether
voter-identification laws unfairly keep poor people and members of minority
groups from going to the polls. The justices will hear arguments from an
Indiana case, in which a federal district judge and a panel of the U.S. Court
of Appeals in January upheld a state law requiring, with certain exceptions,
that someone wanting to vote in person in a primary or general election present
a government-issued photo identification. Before the law was enacted in 2005,
an Indiana voter was required only to sign a book at the polling place, where a
photocopy of the voter’s signature was kept on file. Voter-identification
requirements have divided Democrats and Republicans, and the courts, for years.
In general, Republicans argue that identification laws reduce voter fraud,
while Democrats oppose them on grounds that they lower the turnout among people
who tend to vote Democratic. [NYT
Source] [NYT: Fear but Few
Facts in Debate on Voter I.D.’s]
The man in charge of Google’s privacy policy says the
Internet giant is working on a version of its controversial Street View service
that won’t breach Canadian privacy rules, after federal privacy commissioner
Jennifer Stoddart raised concerns about the service earlier this month. Peter
Fleischer, Google’s global privacy counsel, said in an interview from Montreal
on Monday the company understands Canada has “struck a different balance” than
the U.S. has in terms of what is public and what is private, and that Google is
sensitive to those differences. [Source]
[Privacy
commissioner hopeful about Google proposal to blur Street View] [Why
Google Street View May Violate Privacy Law] [Letter to Google]
[PrivCom
press release]
National regulators need to agree on a basic set of
global privacy protections for the Internet within the next five years, a
senior official with web searcher Google said this week. Peter Fleischer, the
firm’s global privacy counsel, said three quarters of countries had no Internet
privacy standards at a time when the amount of sensitive personal and financial
data on the Web was soaring. [Source]
See also: [$5 billion suit against Google
over privacy, terrorism][Statement of
Claim] See also: [Ordinary citizens
part of ‘surveillance society’: Stoddart]
A special agent with the Department of Commerce has
been charged with unlawfully accessing a database within the Department of
Homeland Security to stalk his former girlfriend and her family. Benjamin
Robinson was indicted by a federal grand jury last week in connection with
allegations that he accessed a government database known as the Treasury
Enforcement Communications System (TECS) at least 163 times to track a woman’s
travel patterns. He is being charged with making a false statement to a
government agency, and unlawfully obtaining information from a protected
computer. Robinson faces a maximum of 10 years in prison and a fine of
$500,000. “Those of us who are sworn to public service must continually strive
to uphold the highest standards of professional conduct,” said U.S. Attorney
Scott N. Schools, in a statement. “Federal officers who violate the public
trust by abusing their official positions to pursue a private vendetta must be
held accountable for those actions.” [Source]
Social networking site MySpace has launched an
initiative to capture personal information from the profile pages and blogs of
its 110 million active users, and then use that to target ads. This news was
announced to investors on September 18 during the quarterly investor
conference. According to the spokesman the company has not issued a statement
about this news to press and would not comment further. This has not stopped
others in the industry from speculating on what this change could mean for
MySpace and online advertising at large. MySpace may be able to almost double
its revenue, from $40 million a month to $70 million a month, thanks to the
data mining solution. “We’ve moved from the ‘build it and they will come’ stage
to the ‘they are here, let’s understand what they like and deliver it while
making money’ stage,” he said. There is a tremendous amount of insight from the
collective user data on social networking sites, such as MySpace. The
information users post about themselves, their likes and dislikes and how and
where they spend their time and money, can all be mined and used for improved
targeting. [Source]
Nearly two thirds (62%) of networking sites users say
they are worried about the safety of their personal data held on these sites,
reveals a survey. The concern is so high that almost one third of users (31%)
have already entered false information about themselves to protect their
identity. One UK Security consultant commented that “as we become citizens of
cyberspace and with social networking sites making details of members visible
through public search engines, we need to learn how to use privacy settings in
better ways and use computers safely.” Users of social networking sites visit
these sites on a regular basis and almost half of them (48%) admit using these
websites at work. Nearly one in four (24%) users log in every day with half of
them logging in several times a day. Up to 45% of users log in at least once a
week. [Source]
A new law designed to regulate how businesses can use
and handle personal information currently is being considered in South Africa.
The South African Law Commission recently issued a discussion paper on privacy
and data protection. The next step will be the drafting of a bill. According to
this Business Day article, Saret van Loggerenberg, senior manager in advisory
services at KPMG, said that South Africa is behind other countries in passing
information privacy laws, and that the “possible development of information
privacy legislation for SA is in line with international trends.” [Source]
A federal judge ruled this week that two provisions of
the USA Patriot Act are unconstitutional because they allow search warrants to
be issued without a showing of probable cause. U.S. District Judge Ann Aiken
ruled that the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, as amended by the Patriot
Act, “now permits the executive branch of government to conduct surveillance
and searches of American citizens without satisfying the probable cause
requirements of the Fourth Amendment.” [Source]
Idaho became the second state to reject the REAL ID
Act, a 2005 measure that creates a de facto national identification card by
requiring states to issue standardized licenses and share citizen information.
Idaho, like Maine, rejected the mandate, citing privacy issues, states rights
and the lack of federal reimbursement. Proposed rules for how states must
comply or else have their citizens stopped from flying or entering federal
courthouses were issued last week. But not all states hate the idea. In other
news, the Identity Project has helped file suit against Alaska’s DMV for
preparing to conform to the REAL ID requirements without getting legislative
approval or following administrative procedures. [Source]
The TJX Companies have announced a yet-to-be-finalized
settlement for several class action suits resulting from various data breaches
over the last few years. TJX, which operates such discount retail chains as
T.J. Maxx and Marshalls in the U.S. and Winners and HomeSense stores in Canada,
is offering claimants three years of credit monitoring (or two additional years
if the customer already has a credit monitoring service), credit insurance for
up to $20,000 in losses, and the cost of replacing driver’s licenses. A second
group will receive one or two $30 vouchers good at any TJX-owned store. [Source]
The percentage of used hard drives containing
sensitive data has not changed much in the last two years. According to
statistics from BT Group, 37% of second-hand hard drives still contain
confidential information from their previous users. BT Group examined 350 hard
drives bought in online auctions. Nineteen percent of the disks had sufficient
data on them to identify the organization of origin, and 65% contained
personally identifiable information. The report, which has yet to be released,
also says that used drives are not highly reliable; 44% of the 133 disks
purchased in the UK did not work [Source]
Employee misconduct and unintentional actions like
errors and omissions are the greatest cause of data security breaches,
according to a survey released by Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu. The firm surveyed
senior information technology executives on the current trends in security and
privacy from 169 major global institutions. Deloitte said 68% of those surveyed
were banks. Almost two-thirds of survey respondents reported repeated external
security breaches, and the top three breaches this year were viruses and worms,
email attacks, and phishing/pharming-- all unwittingly perpetrated via the
customer, Deloitte said. The survey also revealed a shift in priorities from
protecting sensitive data from attack by outsiders to addressing internal
threats. An overwhelming majority of respondents, 91% are concerned about
employees. Nearly 80% cited the human factor as the root cause for information
security failures. According to the Deloitte survey, virtually all respondents
indicated increased security budgets. But 35% said that their investment in
information security is lagging behind business needs and only 20% of U.S.
respondents feel that they have the required skills and competencies to deal
with existing and foreseeable security requirements. The Deloitte survey
identified identity and access management as the top operational initiative of
the year, followed by regulatory compliance, security training and awareness,
governance for security and disaster recovery and business continuity. Two
other recent studies show that some firms are not doing enough planning before
throwing money at the issue. A study
on IT security by the Computing Technology Industry Association (CompTIA)
found that proper training of IT pros could help stave off a security breach.
Meanwhile, a VeriSign
review of PCI Data Security Standard (PCI DSS) assessments it conducted
found that more than half were still stumbling on the path to compliance. [Source]
[Source]
See also: [Malicious
or Careless, the Insider Threat Grows] [Computer Security Institute
report on insider threats] and, finally: [Car
dealers least trusted with personal data: UK Survey]
The UK’s Liberal Democrats object to the “surveillance
society” that they believe has grown up in Britain, and they’ve released
a set of figures on CCTV use that purport to show that the cameras are
ineffective at helping police solve crimes. The data was released by the
London Assembly of the Liberal Democrats, which gathered police data from the
greater London area. According to the information, London police solve only 21%
of all crimes, and the rate of success does not appear to have any correlation
to the number of CCTV cameras installed in each borough. The current data was
gathered to help make a political point. The Liberal Democrats have just
concluded their Autumn
Conference, at which they passed a motion calling for the immediate repeal
of the Identity Cards Act, the destruction of all DNA samples from
people not charged with a crime, and more regulation of CCTV and personal
information. Apart from the recently released numbers, there have been a number
of more rigorous studies done on the topic. The UK’s own Home Office reports that CCTV
helps lower crime rates by about 4 percent. The effect only works so long
as people remain aware of the cameras, though. CCTV is actually much more
effective in car parks, though it has small or no effects in many other
situations. In fact, five of the 22 studies analyzed by the Home Office showed
that CCTV deployments actually correlated with a rise in crime. [Source]
[Figures]
A startup has come up with a new way to make money
from phone calls connected via the Internet, by having software listen to the
calls, then displaying ads on the callers’ computer screens based on the
discussions. The advertising model is similar to that of Google’s Gmail, which
shows ads based on scans of the user’s e-mail correspondence. That idea
initially raised privacy concerns, but those have mostly abated as users have
become comfortable with the system. [Source]
A federal court in Massachusetts has ruled that the
government doesn’t need probable cause to obtain a warrant allowing it to use a
person’s cell phone to track his past movements. According to the ruling by the
U.S. District Court in Massachusetts, law enforcement officials only need to
show the information is “relevant to an ongoing investigation.” In addition,
the district court ruled that an individual’s past movements were not protected
under the Fourth Amendment because the government wasn’t looking to track the
individual’s real-time or future movements. “This is the first decision that’s
been about historical tracking,” said the Electronic Frontier Foundation. [Source] [Decision]
Senators Russ Feingold (D-WI) and John Sununu (R-NH)
have introduced a bill to reform National Security Letters -- demands issued by
FBI agents without a judge’s approval to compel disclosure of financial,
telephone, Internet and other records. Under the proposed NSL Reform Act,
the FBI could still use an NSL to obtain less sensitive information such as a
person’s name, address and account identifying information, but more sensitive
information such as financial details or logs of the e-mail addresses would
require a different process, such as a court order or a subpoena. CDT welcomed
the measure as a response to some of the more egregious problems with NSLs that
were identified in an Inspector General’s report issued in March 2007. [CDT Testimony:
National Security Letters] See also: [Bush
Administration Aiming To Ease Surveillance Concerns]
Beginning on Dec. 15, security clearances will be
required by workers at the ports of Montreal, Halifax, Vancouver, Fraser River
and North Fraser River. As well, security clearances will be required for
workers at the control centres of the St. Lawrence Seaway Management, under
phase I of the Marine Transportation Security Clearance Program. The Marine
Transportation Security Clearance Program was initially announced on Nov. 16. [Source]
--------