FIPA is a nonpartisan organization. Our mandate is to act to protect and enhance information and privacy rights for people in British Columbia, and our focus is on the policies, laws, and practices that uphold or erode these rights. We do not endorse any candidates or political parties.
We do respond to the actions and positions of governments and political parties, though, and we take the claims of elected representatives seriously. BC recently had a change in government that followed closely after the passage of legislation to reform the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act. This combination of events presents the people of BC with an opportunity to press MLAs, political parties, and governments to clarify where they stand on matters related to information and privacy, and to ask them how they plan to translate their rhetoric into action.

British Columbians should be able to find out how public decisions are made and trust government to protect their personal information. The incoming Conservative government defended those principles in opposition. FIPA expects it to put them into practice. The NDP, returning to opposition, must also answer for the laws it passed in government.
Freedom of information helps people understand decisions about their communities, examine public spending and challenge government claims. Privacy protections help people seek public services with confidence about how their personal information will be handled. These rights matter regardless of who holds office.
The Conservatives have already said much about the standards government should meet. Their statements give British Columbians a basis for asking what will change, who will be responsible and when improvements will reach the people using the system.
In 2024, then Conservative leader John Rustad promised to “make all of the information that can be made public, public.”[1] That earlier commitment to proactive disclosure deserves a clear answer from Premier-designate Lorne Doerkson. Which records will his government release routinely, and on what schedule?
During this year’s debate on Bill 9, Conservative MLAs again defended access as a public right. Sharon Hartwell told the Legislature that access is “not a courtesy.”[2] She and other caucus members challenged changes they said would make it easier to delay, restrict or charge for access. Trevor Halford’s motion to postpone second reading for six months put the caucus’s opposition on the legislative record.[3]
Those positions create a reasonable expectation that the new government will remove barriers to access. Opposing Bill 9 did not, by itself, specify a repeal plan or a timetable. The government should now explain how it will address the provisions it opposed and improve service.
Bill 9 expanded the grounds on which the Information and Privacy Commissioner can authorize a public body to disregard a request. The Commissioner remains the decision-maker under section 43. The concern is that broader grounds can limit access even with that independent review. The law also permits fees for copies of certain records available outside the formal request process.[4]
FIPA’s expectations are straightforward: remove the $10 application fee for general records, make more records freely available and resource the staff and records systems needed to respond on time. Publishing selected information must be accompanied by an effective right to request records government has not chosen to release.
The Conservative record also includes serious questions about how government handles personal information.
In the May 21 committee debate, Jody Toor questioned the scope of Connected Services, the framework for sharing information to deliver government services. She asked what information could be collected and shared, whether people would know where it went, how consent would work and what independent oversight would apply.[5]
These questions establish a standard the incoming government should meet. They are not evidence of a specific promise to repeal Connected Services. Doerkson’s government should explain the safeguards it will require before expanding the system.
People need clear information about what is collected, why it is needed, who can access it and how long it is kept. Meaningful choices, effective security and independent scrutiny must be built into service delivery. The government should publish its privacy safeguards and explain how people can obtain and correct their information or challenge its misuse.
The Conservatives also criticized the NDP’s failure to act on the 2022 all-party review of the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, or FIPPA. The committee’s FIPPA for the Future report made 34 recommendations.[6] FIPA welcomed that consensus and called for action.
Our assessment of Bill 9 identified important unfinished work, including a duty to document decisions and extending access rules to the Legislative Assembly’s administrative functions. Records must exist and be properly managed before anyone can obtain them.[7]
The incoming government should publish a response to the committee’s recommendations, identify the reforms it will advance and give dates for delivery. It should also ensure the next statutory review proceeds on time, with meaningful participation by the public, Indigenous governing bodies and people who use the access system.
The incoming opposition has responsibilities for its record. The NDP government introduced the $10 application fee for general FOI requests in 2021 and brought forward Bill 9 in 2026. FIPA opposed measures that weakened access. The Information and Privacy Commissioner has consistently warned that application fees can create barriers.[8] [9]
Returning to opposition does not erase that record. As New Democrats seek information to scrutinize the Conservative government, they should explain which restrictions they now support removing and why. Calls for openness will carry more weight when accompanied by support for reforms that benefit everyone seeking records.
The NDP should press for strong privacy safeguards as well, including scrutiny of the information-sharing powers it helped create. A change in its role is an opportunity to address shortcomings it defended in government.
The BC Green Party also made an important contribution to the debate over access rights. Speaking for the Green caucus, Rob Botterell opposed Bill 9 in its proposed form, identified provisions that should be withdrawn and called for reforms grounded in the 2022 all-party committee’s recommendations.[10]
In committee, Botterell pressed the government to explain the evidence behind new restrictions and whether applicants and members of the public had been consulted. Those questions remain relevant as the incoming government considers changes of its own.[11]
FIPA expects the Greens to carry that scrutiny forward. They should press for the removal of financial barriers, stronger requirements to document decisions and meaningful public participation in reform. Their scrutiny should also extend to privacy safeguards and independent oversight of government information sharing.
The Greens’ contribution should be assessed through the changes they propose and support, as well as the questions they ask. Their defence of access and privacy must remain consistent regardless of which party forms government.
FIPA will assess all parties against their words, their votes and the effects of their decisions. We welcome support for stronger rights from across the Legislature. That support needs to remain consistent when access becomes politically inconvenient.
We will be asking the incoming government to set out, early in its mandate:
All British Columbians can ask their MLA to support those steps. The new government has an opportunity to give practical effect to the rights it defended in opposition. The new opposition has an opportunity to help repair the system it leaves behind. British Columbians are entitled to judge every party by what it does next.
You can find a link to all the identified public statements made by the incoming Government on these topics on our website linked here soon.
[1] “Rustad vows to fix B.C.’s broken freedom of information system” (September 2024), The Breaker, online: https://thebreaker.news/business/rustad-foi-fix/.
[2] British Columbia, Legislative Assembly, Debates (Hansard), 43rd Leg, 2nd Sess, No 171 (4 May 2026) at 5:30 pm (Sharon Hartwell), online: https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-Hansard-n171.html.
[3] British Columbia, Legislative Assembly, Debates (Hansard), 43rd Leg, 2nd Sess, No 173 (5 May 2026) at 1:55 pm (Trevor Halford), online: https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm.
[4] Bill 9, 43rd Leg, 2nd Sess (BC) [pin to the relevant clauses]; Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, RSBC 1996, c 165, ss 43, 71, online: https://www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca/civix/document/id/complete/statreg/96165_00_multi.
[5] British Columbia, Legislative Assembly, Debates (Hansard), 43rd Leg, 2nd Sess, No 181 (21 May 2026) at 3:40 pm–4:30 pm (Jody Toor), online: https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-Hansard-n181.html.
[6] Special Committee to Review the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, FIPPA for the Future (June 2022), online: https://www.leg.bc.ca:443/content/CommitteeDocuments/42nd-parliament/3rd-session/fippa/report/SC-FIPPA-Report_42-3_2022-06-08.pdf; FIPA, “2022 FIPPA report released,” online: https://fipa.bc.ca/2022-fippa-report-released/.
[7] FIPA, “2026 Bill 9 after committee” (27 May 2026), online: https://fipa.bc.ca/2026-bill-9-after-committee.
[8] The Breaker, supra note 1.
[9] Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner for British Columbia, online: https://www.oipc.bc.ca/documents/infographics/2857.
[10] British Columbia, Legislative Assembly, Debates (Hansard), 43rd Leg, 2nd Sess, No 139 (11 March 2026) at 2:50 pm (Rob Botterell), online: https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-Hansard-n139.html.
[11] Debates (Hansard), supra note 5 at 3:15 pm (Rob Botterell).
Our Email distribution: https://app.cyberimpact.com/newsletter-view-online?ct=IKAKd8JFnkW_WwA88i1UeSfArte7Gu_wGFZfeBcEX7x4vTPtMabTQqDa2vNkLH2fw0bPzszOwNGTa3yJ3cLNKqFc2JLBSdnIT1rSM5yysN4Foatg9fo3LAfZAgTeE03o
You help us fulfill our mandate and stay independent. Every contribution – big, small, one-time, or recurring – makes a difference. Click here to donate.